A comparison of john stuart mills and friedrich nietzsches views on utilitarianism

Mill was educated by his father, with the advice and assistance of Jeremy Bentham and Francis Place. Accordingly, the First Formula is not to be interpreted as drafting a moral duty.

This seems to be patently wrong. Since act and rule utilitarianism are incompatible claims about what makes actions morally right, the formulations open up the fundamental question concerning what style of utilitarianism Mill wants to advocate and whether his moral theory forms a consistent whole.

Many people take it to be evident that individuals have absolute, inalienable rights; but they doubt that these rights can be grounded in the principle of utility.

His position can be best understood with recourse to the distinction between the theory of objective rightness and the theory of moral obligation introduced in the last section. In regard to the given description, the fact that the assassination of a human would be objectively right does not imply that the assassination of this human would be morally imperative or allowed.

In actual fact, one can in almost all cases imagine variations in circumstances that would effectively hold a person back from acting how he or she acted.

The First Formula gives a general characterization of practical reason.

John Stuart Mill and Utilitarianism

With perfect knowledge of antecedent conditions and psychological laws, we could predict human behavior with perfect accuracy. Probably the thought will not even occur to him. According to Mill, our moral obligations result from the justified part of the moral code of our society; and the task of moral philosophy consists in bringing the moral code of a society in better accordance with the principle of utility.

An action has a high positive value on the scale of preference, if its tendency to facilitate happiness is high. Both claims cannot be reconciled, or so it seems, and this is the problem.

The preparedness to take revenge tends to deter aggression in the first place. Nietzsche parries this common interpretation in Daybreak by conceding, "in this book faith in morality is withdrawn—but Why? Mill worked very hard to hammer the fifth chapter into shape and his success has great meaning for him.

This helps to explain why the sentiment is so widespread and vehement. Utilitarianism is a philosophy which has been around for centuries, and is still active and popular in the modern world.

Thus Mill is not to blame for failing to make explicit which of the two approaches he advocates. Because Nietzsche considers utilitarianism a secular offspring of Christian morality, many of his global attacks on utilitarianism resemble his more familiar critique of Christian "slave morality"—the morality of the herd.

Riley, Jonathan,Liberal Utilitarianism. He maintains that we name a type of action morally wrong if we think that it should be sanctioned either through formal punishment, public disapproval external sanctions or through a bad conscience internal sanctions.

It is true that some pleasures may be "base"; however, this does not mean that all of them are:John Stuart Mill believed in an ethical theory known as utilitarianism and his theory is based on the principle of giving the greatest happiness.

views as a •consecration of Utilitarianism John Stuart Mill 1: General remarks most scornfully reject its authority. And every school of thought admits that the influence of actions on happiness is a very significant and even predominant consideration in many of the details of morals, however unwilling they may.

Friedrich Nietzsche (philosopher, author) Philosophy. What were Nietzsche's views on utilitarianism? Update Cancel. ad by Truthfinder. Locate anyone by entering a name, it's that simple. A popular site reveals data on millions of Americans.

Two easy steps: enter name and state.

One the main philosophers of utilitarianism was John Stuart Mill. The views of John Stuart Mill on utilitarianism and how it differs from Bentham’s views were given much attention in the paper.

We will write a custom essay sample on John Stuart Mill and Utilitarianism. A Comparison of John Stuart Mill's and Friedrich Nietzsche's VIews on Utilitarianism PAGES 4.

John Stuart Mill: Ethics

WORDS 1, View Full Essay. More essays like this: Not sure what I'd do without @Kibin - Alfredo Alvarez, student @ Miami University.

Exactly what I needed. - Jenna Kraig, student @ UCLA. Issuu is a digital publishing platform that makes it simple to publish magazines. and more online Easily a comparison of john stuart mills and friedrich nietzsches views on utilitarianism share your publications and get. books.

A comparison of john stuart mills and friedrich nietzsches views on utilitarianism
Rated 3/5 based on 18 review